Chartered Accountant
Bookmark and Share
click here to subscribe our newsletter
 
 
Corporate News *  Old VAT bill book alone can’t prove GST evasion: GSTAT. *  No consignment note, No GTA service tax: CESTAT quashes Rs. 2.73 Crore demand against truck operator. *  70:30 GST formula can’t be compulsorily applied to Pre-2019 solar EPC supplies: Supreme Court. *  GST sanction objection can’t invalidate entire FIR also alleging BNS offences: Calcutta High Court. *  Printing Question Papers, Marksheets, Degree Certificates For Educational Institutions Exempt From GST: AAR *  Kraft paper bags attract 5% GST with ITC: AAR *  Agricultural use doesn’t entitle plastic nursery pots And seedling trays to lower GST; 18% applies: AAR *  E-Way Bill numbers to expand to 14 digits from January 1, 2027; GSTN advises software and API updates. *  Seized vehicle’s release sought over 6 month customs notice limit: Gauhati High Court directs decision on interim custody plea. *  ICEGATE glitch: CESTAT allows appeal against denial of ?4.33 Lakh customs interest refund. *  Missing E-way bill: GSTAT quashes unreasoned relief order, remands tax and penalty dispute. *  Taxpayer can’t be worse off after own appeal: GSTAT caps tax, penalty at ?45 lakh each in suppressed sales case. *  GSTR-3B–GSTR-2A mismatch alone can’t sustain input tax credit demand: GSTAT *  CBIC directs no further GST arrests, bars notices below Rs. 10K and restricts E-way bill checks. *  Importer alleges backdated DIN in arrest documents: Mumbai Court grants bail in ?31.86 crore Customs Duty evasion case. *  GST interest recovery after time-barred assessment set aside: MP High Court *  GST demand based on return scrutiny requires prior ASMT-10 notice: Gauhati High Court. *  GST hearing notices sent to wrong email: disputed service must be examined in statutory appeal: Delhi High Court *  Car dealer’s sales incentives, trade discounts not liable to service tax: CESTAT *  GSTAT may refuse appeals involving up to Rs. 50,000: GSTAT. *  Insurance premium remitted to insurer cannot be added to lender’s taxable service value: CESTAT. *  GST provisional attachment ends after one year: Delhi High Court declines immediate release of ?57.89 Lakh. *  Customs can’t apply new 100-unit import limit retrospectively: Telangana High Court quashes confiscation of used MFDs. *  E-Way bill Part-B lapse alone can’t justify GST penalty without intent to evade tax: GSTAT. *  Railway construction work doesn’t automatically qualify for 12% GST: GSTAT. *  GST exemption for northeast helicopter travel, coffee curing; GTA relief restricted for E-commerce goods from 1 November, 2026: FinMin. *  GST amendment allows same-line business ITC for hotels, restaurants and caterers from 1 November, 2026: FinMin. *  GST exemption covers banks’ internal fund transfer interest; NBFC co-lending services taxable: CBIC. *  Rs. 11,000 crore customs demand: volkswagen cites five-year limit, centre alleges delayed disclosure before Bombay High Court. *  GST e-invoice data services to face 28-hour downtime from october 31; GSTR-1 auto-population affected.
Subject News *  Customs Penalties u/s 112, 114 doesn’t bar special warehouse licence: CESTAT. *  Supplies to SEZ developers before December 2008 eligible for CENVAT relief: Karnataka High Court. *  Customs can’t club demands to meet Rs. 1 crore appeal limit: Delhi High Court. *  GST on mining royalty: Gujarat High Court bars final orders without its permission, allows adjudication to continue. *  Dept. can’t challenge fine alone while leaving related penalty findings uncontested: GSTAT. *  Engineering consultancy for Indian project supplied to Japan not liable to service tax: CESTAT. *  Export overvaluation can be examined without fresh customs valuation: Delhi High court restores drawback recovery order. *  Wrong TRAN-1 column can’t defeat admitted Rs. 6.29 crore GST transitional credit: Bombay High Court. *  Bombay High Court quashes customs order after challenge over alleged AI-generated Supreme Court judgments. *  DGFT can’t reject import registration over HS code mismatch without opportunity to explain: Bombay High Court. *  GST notice despite advance ruling: Gujarat High court restrains final order without its permission. *  Common GST SCN not defective merely because it covers multiple noticees: Delhi High Court. *  GST interest recovery after time-barred assessment set aside: MP High Court. *  Excess stock estimated by eye can’t justify GST confiscation: GSTAT *  Customs can’t retain seized cash without timely notice or valid extension: Supreme Court leaves Rs. 1 lakh costs against DRI intact. *  Surat DGGI | further investigation can’t continue endlessly: Gujarat High Court grants bail in Rs. 43–44 crore fake GST input tax credit case. *  Customs broker’s hearsay statement, ?1.5 lakh transfer insufficient to establish nexus with heroin import: Bombay High Court grants NDPS bail. *  Seized diary entries alone can’t establish suppressed GST turnover without transaction-wise verification: GSTAT. *  Invoice numbering error can’t justify detention of areca nuts, ?6.65 lakh GST penalty: GSTAT. *  GST pre-deposit refund can’t be denied merely because dept. files appeal: CBIC. *  No reverse charge service tax on services received before April 18, 2006: CESTAT. *  Supplier’s retrospective GST cancellation alone can’t deny input tax credit; fraud must be established under section 74: GSTAT. *  E-Invoice portal glitch can’t justify 200% GST penalty without intent to evade tax: GSTAT. *  Cascading effect’ can’t override ?2 crore appeal limit: Delhi High Court dismisses Service Tax Appeals. *  GSTR-1 duplication can’t create tax liability without second supply: GSTAT. *  GST penalty can’t rest on driver’s uncorroborated statement when iron scrap matches valid documents: GSTAT. *  Accountant’s absence delayed stock entries: GSTAT rejects deptartment’s plea for confiscation. *  GST registration restored: Deptartment’s appeal becomes infructuous despite illegal delay condonation: GSTAT. *  Belated ITC-03 filing warrants fresh review of GST composition scheme denial: Madras High Court *  GST appeals can’t be dismissed for non-prosecution: GSTAT.  

Comments

Print   |    |  Comment

PJ/Case Laws/2012-13/1174

- Recovery of excess drawback – Whether the drawback sanctioning authority is right in demanding the excess paid drawback on revision/re fixation of brand rate of drawback?
Case: IN RE: 3M INDIA LTD.
 
Citation: 2012 (281) E.L.T. 465 (G.O.I.)
 
Issue:- Recovery of excess drawback – Whether the drawback sanctioning authority is right in demanding the excess paid drawback on revision/re fixation of brand rate of drawback?
Brief Facts: - M/s. 3 M India Ltd. exported EPDXY Resin Powder and claimed duty drawback under Brand Rate fixed by Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, LTU., Bangalore. The brand rate was subse­quently revised by Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, LTU, Bangalore, by letter vide F.No. IV /06/08/2008/GLT-III/LTU, dated 16-6-2008.As per the re­vised brand rate letters M/s. 3 M India Ltd. had availed excess drawback amount of Rs. 12,74,538/-. Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the applicant for the recovery of excess Drawback amount of Rs. 12,74,542/-, by the original authority. Subsequently, the original authority confirmed the demand of excess paid drawback.
Being aggrieved by the said Order-in-Original, applicant filed appeal before Commissioner (Appeals), who rejected the same.
Being aggrieved by the Impugned Order-in-Appeal, the applicant has filed this revision application under Section 129DD of Customs Act, 1962 be­fore Central Government.
Appellant’s Contention: - The Appellants submit that they had filed bills of entry for the goods imported during the dispute period providing all details of the import goods for duty drawback under Sub-Heading No. 3907 30 90. The above bills of entry were assessed in the entirety by the officers and such assessments have not been challenged by the department. Consequently, the entire assessments done in the respective bills of entry have become final.
The Appellants submit that the drawback amounts of Rs. 23,31,647/- have been sanctioned by the proper officer of Customs on the ba­sis of the assessment done in the shipping bills. The said amounts have been given to the Appellants either by way of cheque or by way of direct credit to the account. The Appellants submit that the above sanction order of the drawback have not been challenged so far in any manner known to law. The order sanc­tioning the refund is not challenged by the department before an appropriate authority and has not been set aside in the process known to law, the present proceeding seeking recovery of the drawback is legally not sustainable and the impugned order-in-appeal is liable to be set aside.
 The case of the department is that the drawback sanctioned was not admissible to them on the ground that the debit in DEPB could not be treated as duty paid. Such a ground to recover drawback already sanctioned after due con­sideration of all material factors cannot be termed as 'erroneous'. Consequently, the Appellants submit that Rule 16 would not apply in this case at all. If Rule 16 is not applicable in this case, in view of the fact that the drawback sanctioned is not erroneous, then, there is no provision to demand or recover such drawback or that by the argument, Rule 16 is rendered nugatory. Rule 16 would indeed come into play when the drawback sanctioned needs to be recovered on account of mistaken calculation and technical error. For Instance of rates of drawback is Rs. 20 but the drawback sanctioned is say Rs. 21, then the recovery of the excess amount of Rs. 1 sanctioned as a result of mistaken calculation would be gov­erned by Rule 16. Similarly, if the product covered under the drawback schedule is of specification A, but the drawback sanctioned is for product B, due to any technical error then, again, the drawback sanctioned can be recovered by invok­ing Rule 16.
 
The appellants contended that the ground for revision/re-fixation of brand rate itself is challenged as untenable in law and tainted by legal errors and consequently, the impugned Order all suffers from the same legal errors and therefore not sustainable. The Applicants submit that the thrust of the depart­ment's contention for revising/re-fixing the brand rate was that import of inputs by paying the BCD through could not be construed as 'duty paid' and this is en­tirely wrong legal proposition contrary to scheme of DEPB/Drawback as con­tained in the Foreign Trade Policy (FTP) and the Customs Act respectively. One may pay any type of customs duty as defined in Section 2(15) of the Customs Act, 1962 though the DEPB as long as such duty is levied under Section 12 of the Customs Act read with the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 or any other law for the time being in force.
The Applicant was not given an opportunity to oppose the re-fixation of drawback rates. Hence, the department has failed to appreciate the pleas made by the Applicants. The impugned order is therefore bad in law and is liable to set aside.
There is no provision under the Drawback Rules, 1995 for either re-fixation or revision of `brand rates' inasmuch as the original fixation of duty drawback rates itself examining the duty-paid nature of the inputs and fixation of duty drawback only thereafter. It is for this precise reason that elaborate documentation and forms have been prescribed.
 
 
Respondent’s Contention: - The Respondent contended that the pleas of the applicant before original authority basically related to challenging the revision of brand rates by the Central Excise authority. The jurisdiction for fixation or revision of brand rates of drawback under Rules 6 & 7 of the Drawback Rules, 1995 lies with the Central Excise. Hence, the original authority in the present case had no jurisdiction to consider pleas raised in this re­gard. This is also clearly mentioned in the order in specific terms by mentioning that 'The role of this office in this case is limited to sanction of drawback based on the brand rate fixed by the Central Excise Authority under Rule 6 or 7 of the Drawback Rules. This office has no jurisdiction or competence to alter or modify the rates fixed as above. In this case the brand rates were fixed by Central Excise, Bangalore and same were revised and re fixed after consideration of certain as­pects. Hence these submissions ought to be made before the authorities who had revised the brand rates.
Further he held that appellant's plea that interest provision u/s 75A (2) was not existing prior to 11-5-2007 is not relevant to facts of the present case since the Drawback amount in the present case was paid in 2008. Interest on excess payment received by the Appellant is recoverable under provisions of Section 75A (2), which came into effect from 11-5-2007, read with Rule 16 of the Drawback Rules, 1995. Appel­lant's plea against recovery of interest on drawback amount is irrelevant and un­tenable.
He further states that the Appellant has wrongly stated that even while re-fixing the drawback rates the Department had not intimated the Appellant and it was only when the Respondent was issued notice for recovery of excess drawback that the Appellant got opportunity of the first time to oppose re-fixation of drawback rates. This ground raised by the Appellant is factually incorrect and misleading. It may be seen from the Annexure E, enclosed at page 51 and Annexure G, en­closed at page go to 71 to the Appeal Memorandum that every letter revising brand rate has not only been communicated to the Appellant but they are also having a copy of it available with them which they have enclosed to the Appeal. It is further seen that the Appellant vide letters dated 18-6-2008 & 30-6-2008, en­closed to the Appeal as Annexure H at page 73 and Annexure F at page 55, ad­dressed to the Central Excise, Bangalore had in fact opposed revision of brand rates. Therefore, it is clear from the evidence on record that not only the Appel­lant had sufficient time and opportunity to oppose revision of the brand rate let­ters by the Central Excise authority from the date of such revision on June 2008 till their appearance before the Respondent for personal hearing in February 2009, but in fact they did avail such an opportunity.
Reasoning of Judgment: - Government held that the applicant initially filed claim for drawback as per brand rate fixed by the LTU, Bangalore, which was sanctioned by the original authority, (drawback sanctioning authority).Subsequently the LTU, Bangalore revised/refixed brand rate of drawback in case of the applicant. In view of revised rate of brand rate of duty drawback, the original authority issued Show Cause Notice for recovery of excess paid drawback and subsequently confirmed the same, which was upheld by the appellate authority.
Further it was held that the LTU, Bangalore the proper authority, initially fixed brand rate of drawback, on the basis of which drawback was sanc­tioned by the original authority. In terms of Rule 6 of the Customs, Central Excise Duties and Service Tax Drawback Rules, 1995 the authority of fixation of Brand Rate of Drawback lies with the Jurisdictional Commissioner of Central Excise or Commissioner of Customs, as the case may be. Applicant being large Tax Payer unit, the LTU, Bangalore was the proper authority to fix /refix /revise the brand rate of drawback. The Drawback Sanctioning authority sanctions the drawback as fixed by the proper authority. If the applicants were aggrieved by the re-fixing of brand rate of drawback of duty by the LW, Bangalore; they should have chal­lenged such revisions/refixing of brand rate of drawback, which they failed to do. Once the brand rate is revised by the proper authority; the original authority i.e. drawback sanctioning authority was required to take consequential action w.r.t. revision of brand rate. As such, the Drawback sanctioning authority was right in demanding excess paid drawback in terms of Rule 16 of Drawback Rules, 1998.
It was further held that from the contention of the appellant it is clear that where amount of drawback and interest has been paid erroneously or the amount is paid in excess of entitlement the excess paid amount is liable to be recovered. There is no ambiguity in these recovery provisions.
Government finds support from the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of Bombay in this case of M/s. Indian Dye Stuff Industries Ltd. v. U01 reported as 2003 (161) E.L.T. 12 (Born.) wherein it was held that "Section 11A of Central Ex­cise Act, 1944 being an independent substantive provision, the appellate pro­ceedings are not required to be initiated before issuing Show Cause Notice under Section 11A if there are grounds existing such as Short Levy, short recovery or erroneous refund etc. Section 11A is an independent substantive provision and it is a complete code in itself for realisation of excise duty erroneously refunded. There are no pre-conditions attached for issuance of notice under Section 11A." The said judgment of Bombay High Court has been upheld by Hon'ble Supreme Court reported as 2004 (163) E.L.T. A56 (S.C.). This judgment is further followed by Tribunal in the case of C.C.E., Ahmedabad v. Maize Products - 2004 (167) E.L.T. 174 (T) and Bharat Box Factory Ltd. v. C.C.E. Ludhiana 2005 (183) E.L.T. 461 (Tn. Del.).
Government observes that similar recovery provisions exist in the Rule 16 ibid. So the ratio of above said judgment of Bombay High Court is squarely applicable to this case. Under such circumstances, the drawback sanc­tioning authority was right in confirming the said demand of excess paid draw­back in terms of Rule 16 of Customs, Central Excise Duties and Service Tax Drawback Rules, 1995. 
Decision: - The application was rejected.
 
Department News


Query

 
PRADEEP JAIN, F.C.A.

Head Office : -

Address :
"SUGYAN", H - 29, SHASTRI NAGAR, JODHPUR (RAJ.) - 342003

Phone No. :
0291 - 2439496, 0291 - 3258496

Mobile No. :
09314722236

Fax No. :0291 - 2439496


Branch Office : -

Address:
1008, 10th FLOOR, SUKH SAGAR COMPLEX,
NEAR FORTUNE LANDMARK HOTEL, USMANPURA,
ASHRAM ROAD, AHMEDABAD-380013

Phone No. :
079-32999496, 27560043

Mobile No. :
093777659496, 09377649496

E-mail :pradeep@capradeepjain.com