Chartered Accountant
Bookmark and Share
click here to subscribe our newsletter
 
 
Corporate News *   Government extends deadline for GST returns filing for taxpayers affected by cyclones *  GST on banks' 'free services' may be passed on to customers *   Govt staring at a shortfall of Rs 500 bn to Rs 1 trn in GST collection? *  Ministry seeks to bring aviation fuel under GST. *  Centre, states apportion Rs 33,000 cr IGST in November. *  GST: Government Extends Deadline For Filing TDS Returns For Oct.-Dec. To January 2019 *  Indirect Tax Evasion During April-October Stands At Rs 29,088 Crore *   Tax Collection Growing By 15-20 Per Cent Every Year: Arun Jaitley *   GST Compensation Paid To States Declines To Rs 11,900 Crore in August-September *  GST Practitioners Enrollment Exam In December *  GST can’t be Deducted from Salary of Employees sponsored by UPNL: Uttarakhand HC *  Chennai businessman held for Rs 61 crore GST evasion . *  Govt issues Advisory to UIN Entities claiming GST Refunds *  GST paid under a Wrong Head by Mistake can be Transferred to the Right Head: Kerala HC *  CBIC clarifies Scope of Principal and Agent Relationship *  Tea Board of India liable to collect TCS from Tea producers and Auctioneers: CBIC *  Rs 82,775 Cr to Exporters Cleared, Rs 5,400 Cr Pending as on Oct 31 *  Kerala HC orders to take Photographs of Goods since Issue was Misclassification *  Changes in E-way Bill from 16th November 2018 *  Over 2 lakh assessees who migrated from VAT regime opt out of GST net *  GST Practitioners Enrollment Exam In December *   Bombay HC asks Petitioners seeking amendment in GST TRAN 1 to make representation before CBIC; directs CBIC to address within 12 weeks *   Congress will bring single slab GST: Rahul Gandhi *   Centre, states apportion Rs 32,000 crore IGST in October *   GST payers to be divided into four categories for targeted approach *   Centre contemplating bringing petrol, diesel under GST *    Event Management Support Services provided in Goa to a Registered Person in Maharashtra subject to Integrated GST: AAR   *   Haryana to form GST Appellate Tribunal *  Unprecedented tax reforms undertaken by Indian Customs for enhancing easy of doing business. *  Companies rush to match input tax credit with vendor returns
Subject News *   GST returns witness substantial increase in J&K: Tax dept *   Banks to impose GST on ATM usage, issue of cheque books, additional credit cards *   Realtors want different GST rates based on location of projects *  Keeping it simple: Reconciliation of GST data in 5 steps. *  India Inc seeks more time for filing GST annual returns, audit reports. *  Simplified GST return forms to be rolled out from April 1: Revenue Secretary *  CAIT urges FM Arun Jaitley to extend last date for GST filing to March 2019 . *  Air conditioners, TVs may get cheaper as GST Council likely to slash tax rate to 18% *  Key points for first ever filing of GST Annual returns. *  Government extends GST annual return filing date to March 31, 2019 *  Furnishing GST annual return extend deadline by 3 months: ICAI to CBIC *  Credit to MSEs up 5 times to Rs 1.23 lakh crore post GST: SBI study *  Need GST Council like federal institution in healthcare, farm sector: Arun Jaitley. *   How GST will cruise ahead with new-age tech ? *  GST a ‘monumental reform’: finance minister Arun Jaitley *  AB Pandey takes over as revenue secy; to focus on enhanced tax compliance via technology integration.   *  GST revenue mop up at ₹97,637 cr in Nov *   Process of getting ATF under GST bracket underway, says Jayant Sinha *   Arun Jaitley to present interim budget in February, may include tax measures *   Tax soup for restaurants not sharing service charges with staff *   Amendments to State GST Act introduced *  NAA drops Anti-profiteering charges against Fab India. *  Gur-ta-Gaddi Tercentenary Celebration is a Religious Event: CESTAT quashes Service Tax Demand for setting up Temporary Camps  *  Strange Attitude of Dept insisting Payment of Tax in Cash or DD is against the Spirit of GST: Kerala HC *  Levy of GST on Liquor License Fees. *  GST Evasion: Two more arrested in Hyderabad *  CBIC to Monitor Grievances of MSMEs on a Daily basis *  India's economic growth held back due to note ban, GST: Raghuram Rajan *  Bengaluru:Rs 1,200 Crore GST Fraud Busted *   Re-Opening of GST TRAN-1 to Rectify Errors; Bombay HC asks CBIC to resolve Issue within 12 Weeks.  

Comments

Print   |    |  Comment

PJ/Case Law/2016-17/3442

Whether condonation of delay allowed if appeal wrongly filed under different jurisdiction?
Case:-LATHIA INDUSTRIES SUPPLIES CO. PVT. LTD. VersusCESTAT WEST ZONAL BENCH
Citation:-2016 (342) E.L.T. 535 (Guj.)
Issue:- Whether condonation of delay allowed if appeal wrongly filed under different jurisdiction?
Brief facts:- This petition was filed with following relief :-
“[A] Your Lordships may be pleased to quash and set aside the impugned Order No. A/10806/2014, dated 10-4-2014 passed by the Hon’ble CESTAT, West Zonal Bench, Ahmedabad. Application no. and further be pleased to quash and set aside the Order-in-Appeal No. 185/2012(Ahd-II)CE/AK/Commr(A)/Ahd., dated 30-9-2013 and Order-in-Original No. 9/AC/2012, dated 19-10-2012, passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, Division I, Ahmedabad in the interest of justice;”
The brief facts are as under :-
The petitioner-company was engaged in business of manufacture of goods like Rubber Roll, Rubber Blanker, etc. and was availing exemption scheme as a Small Scale Industrial Unit.
The Department alleged that the petitioner-company had wrongly availed Cenvat credit in relation to certain items like Rubber/Ebonite Roll, for which show cause notice dated 9-8-2012 was issued calling upon the petitioner to show cause as to why Cenvat credit of Rs. 4,90,159/- be not reversed on account of such wrongful availement. The Deputy Commissioner confirmed the demand in the show cause notice by passing Order-in-Original dated 19-10-2012.
Aggrieved by the Order-in-Original, the petitioner preferred appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals-I) and as there was delay of 64 days, filed a separate application for condonation of delay. The ground for delay as contended by the petitioner was that under a mistake, the appeal came to be filed before a wrong forum of the same Department and when such mistake was realized, the aforementioned delay had occurred.
The Commissioner (Appeals-I), Central Excise, Ahmedabad dismissed the application for condonation of delay in view of Section 35 of the Central Excise Act. Such order came to be passed on 30-9-2013.
The petitioner preferred appeal before the CESTAT against order dated 30-9-2013 and CESTAT vide order dated 10-4-2014 rejected the appeal.
 
Appellant’s contention:-Learned Senior Advocate Shri Deven Parikh with learned Advocate Shri Kunal Nanavati for the petitioner submitted that in fact when the appeal came to be filed against the Order-in-Original, there was no delay. However, such appeal was filed before the Commissioner (Appeals) having a different jurisdiction instead of filing such appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals-I), Central Excise, Ahmedabad. Learned Senior Advocate took through the document at Annexure-G which bore the stamp of the appeal having been filed before a different forum and contended that the view taken by the Commissioner (Appeals) as well as CESTAT was hyper-technical in nature and that on merits, the petitioner had an excellent case which required adjudication rather than being scuttled on technical grounds.
 
Respondent’s contention:- Learned Advocate Shri Chintan Dave appearing for the Department had filed an affidavit in the Civil Application to answer this contention of the petitioner. He had also produced xerox copy of the Registers of the concerned Department. Despite this position, the Court had called upon learned Advocate Shri Dave to personally verify the Registers and verify the claim made by the petitioner with regard to filing of the appeal before a wrong forum, to which Shri Dave stated that he had personally verified the Inward Register maintained by the office where according to the petitioner the appeal was initially filed and had confirmed that such appeal was indeed filed before that authority. He therefore urged that he would not seriously object if the matter was remanded back to the stage of Commissioner (Appeals).
 
Reasoning of judgement:-In view of the aforementioned fact situation, on this short ground, the Court was inclined to remain the matter back to the state of appeal to be heard by the Commissioner (Appeals-I), Central Excise, Ahmedabad. The Commissioner (Appeals) took into consideration the contentions of the petitioner regarding filing of the appeal in time, but before a different forum in accordance with law. 
Accordingly, the petition was allowed to the aforesaid extent. The matter was remanded back, to be heard by the Commissioner (Appeals-I), Central Excise, Ahmedabad. Considering the period that had lapsed, the Commissioner (Appeals) may take up hearing of this case expeditiously. Rule was made absolute. No order as to costs.
In view of the order passed in the main matter, CA does not survive. Disposed of accordingly.
 
Decision:-Petition allowed.
Comment:- The analogy of case was that if delay in filing the appeal occurs due to the fact that the appeal is mistakenly filed before a wrong forum of the same Department and the petitioner corrects the samewhen such mistake is realized, then the application for condonation of delay cannot be dismissed as the appeal cannot be quashed on technical grounds.
 
Prepared by: RAKSHAY TATER
 
Department News


Query

 
PRADEEP JAIN, F.C.A.

Head Office : -

Address :
"SUGYAN", H - 29, SHASTRI NAGAR, JODHPUR (RAJ.) - 342003

Phone No. :
0291 - 2439496, 0291 - 3258496

Mobile No. :
09314722236

Fax No. :0291 - 2439496


Branch Office : -

Address:
1008, 10th FLOOR, SUKH SAGAR COMPLEX,
NEAR FORTUNE LANDMARK HOTEL, USMANPURA,
ASHRAM ROAD, AHMEDABAD-380013

Phone No. :
079-32999496, 27560043

Mobile No. :
093777659496, 09377649496

E-mail :pradeep@capradeepjain.com