Chartered Accountant
Bookmark and Share
click here to subscribe our newsletter
 
 
Corporate News *   Non-Tariff Charges Except Cheque Dishonour Fee is exempted from GST: AAAR *   GST: Rs 50,000 crore tax shortfall upsets budget maths *   Arun Jaitley favours GST council-like structure for healthcare, agriculture   *   Traders are not Annoyed with GST, CAIT Writes to Rahul Gandhi   *   March GST collection may touch Rs 1 lakh crore *   For biscuit companies, this is how the cookie crumbles post GST *   No arrest can be made without following procedures in GST evasion cases: HC *   White goods firms under NAA lens for pocketing GST rate cuts   *   Cos can raise product weight in lieu of price cut to pass on GST benefit   *   GST could have been implemented after trial run: Singhvi   *   DRI detects Rs 3.25 cr tax evasion in sale of complimentary IPL tickets   *   Jaitley: Consensus is the secret behind GST’s success   *   Starbucks may face fine for ‘profiteering’ after GST rate cut *   Simpler GST turns out to be bad business for India’s tax consultants   *  Cloudtail India fined Rs 11 lakh by GST anti-profiteering authority *  GSTN Alert: Two New Features added in the Portal *   GST: TVS Motor joins Hero MotoCorp to seek reduction in rate on two-wheelers *   SPARC gets GST notice for ₹46.04 crore *   GST on service sector: Vague orders by advance ruling authorities spell trouble *   Jubilant FoodWorks slapped with Rs 41.42 crore Demand by GST Anti-Profiteering Authority *   Kerala High Court dismisses 3,250 Petitions challenging VAT Assessments post GST *  Rs 230-crore GST scam by Tamil Nadu steel traders unearthed *  Telcos seek GST waiver on payments to govt, Rs 35K-cr input credit adjustment *  Domino's Pizza fined for not passing GST rate cut benefits to customers   *  Patanjali dealer fined for not passing on GST rate cut to consumers *  Foxconn awaiting Rs 1,000 crore GST refund *   Hyderabad: Probe reveals shell firms floated only for GST fraud *  Firm evades Rs 1.27-crore GST; proprietor booked *   Tax Rate on Fly Ash Bricks:- Condition of 90% or more fly ash content *  Ahmedabad CGST officials bust fake GST invoice racket worth Rs 175 crore
Subject News *   Discounts granted must be deducted from Invoice Value to avail Input Tax Credit: AAR *   Lodging along with Food to Students by a Private Boarding House is a Composite Supply, 18% GST applicable: AAR *   Gold Schemes Offered to Customers not eligible for GST Input Tax Credit: AAR  *   GSTN adds New Feature in Portal *   GST: Solar heater parts taxed at 18% *   GST Council's plan for real estate sector may not find many takers   *   Relief to exporters; govt extends IGST, compensation cess exemption for various export plans   *   Consumer Goods Makers Won’t Be Taxed On Buy-One-Get-One-Free Offers *   GST: Unused ITC for half-built houses to be reversed *   GST tribunal proposed at Allahabad, regional benches in 19 districts: Govt   *   GST officials detect tax fraud of Rs 224 cr by 8 companies *   GST appellate body clears air on tax credit for sweet shop vs restaurant *   GST Council to meet on March 19 to finalise real estate tax structure *  Government has said : GST does not apply on the TCS amount *  Solar power generation 5.8 per cent costlier with GST: Report  *  The Federation of Automobile Dealers Associations Seeking Rollback Of GST Amendments *  Government notified April 1 Date Set For Availing Increased GST Exemption Limit, Composition Scheme *  New GST return forms released; compliance process simplified from April 1 *  Realtors seek clarity on GST exemption on development rights *  Govt issues order on ‘removal of difficulties’ in GST *  GST collections drop to Rs 97,247 cr in Feb; rate cuts may have hit mop-up *  There are dark clouds on the horizon when it comes to GST *  GST: DGGI seizes record of Yarn Firms in Ludhiana *  GST Evasion worth Rs 650 crore unearthed in Maharashtra *  GST: Delhi Govt targets Rs 29,000 crore Revenue for Next Year *  Breaking shackles: How GST ended the era of captive warehousing *  Transparency and simplicity in the tax regime are casualties of the GST Council’s recent decisions. *  Reduction in GST rate leads to a drop in price? Real estate a test case for broader changes *  With GST rate cut, you have another reason to buy a house *  GST Commissionerate Hails Mahesh Babu  

Comments

Print   |    |  Comment

PJ/Case Law/2016-2017/3449

whether Cenvat credit on input services, such as, commissioning and installation, housekeeping services, air travel services and rent-a-cab services shall be allowed ?

Case-GODREJ & BOYCE MFG. CO. LTD. Versus COMMISSIONER OF C. EX., CHENNAI-II
 
Citation-  2017(48)S.T.R.88 ( Tri. –Chennai)

Brief Facts-The brief facts of the case are that the appellant-assessee are engaged in the manufacture of steel furniture falling under Chapter 94 of the Central Tariff Act, 1985. They have availed Cenvat credit for excise duty paid on inputs and capital goods and they have availed Cenvat credit of Service Tax paid on input services. The appellants were issued with the show cause notice dated 1-2-2013 requiring them to reverse the credit. The appellant has contended that these services are input services as per definition in Rule 2(l) of CCR and are eligible to avail credit of the services. The Additional Commissioner disallowed the credit on input services to the extent of Rs. 25,49,624/- as per the chart given under and also imposed penalty of Rs. 2,00,000/-.

S. No. Input Services Amount
1. Rent-a-cab Services Rs. 25,234/-
2. Air Travel Charges Rs. 18,389/-
3. CHA Services Rs. 4,69,500/-
4. Sweeping & Cleaning charges Rs. 2,36,285/-
5. Commissioning & Installation Rs. 18,000,216/-

the Learned Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the order of the adjudicating authority to the extent of Rs. 20,80,124/- and set aside the recovery of Cenvat credit on Customs House Agent Service to the extent of Rs. 4,69,500/- and also confirmed the penalty of Rs. 2,00,000/-.
 
Appellant’s Contention-Ld. Counsels Ms. V. Ubhaya Bharathi and Ms. Minchu Mariam Punnoose, appearing on behalf of the appellant submitted that the input services are essential for the assessee and the same are eligible for Cenvat credit. One service after the other was dealt with and they submitted that with respect to Commission and installation services, the very activity of manufacture of the final products would be complete only when the goods are installed in the premises of the customer and therefore without installation, manufacturing process would be incomplete and manufacture does not stop with emergence of the final product alone. Thus, commissioning and installation without which manufacturing activity would not get completed, squarely falls within the definition of “input service” and therefore, Service Tax paid on such services would be eligible for Cenvat credit and placed reliance upon the Order of the Additional Commissioner dated 7-7-2009 in their own case. They submitted that with respect to Housekeeping services, the appellants are under a statutory obligation prescribed under Section 11 of the Factories Act, 1948, to maintain the factory premises neat and clean and that expenditure incurred towards the same, when included in the value of the final product, credit on such services cannot be denied and placed reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of Commissioner of C. Ex & ST, LTU Chennai v. Rane TRW Steering Systems Ltd. [2015 (39)S.T.R.13 (Mad.)] and the decision of this Hon’ble Court in the case of Hinduja Foundries Ltd. v. Commissioner of C. Ex, Chennai-I [2016 (42)S.T.R.494 (Tribunal)].
The ld. Counsels further submitted that with respect to air travel services, such services were employed only for the Company’s executives to travel in order to upgrade the technology and ensure uninterrupted production with a better quality. Such services were not employed for the employee’s personal needs. Therefore Service Tax paid on such services would be eligible to the appellants as Cenvat credit and placed reliance on the decision of this Hon’ble Tribunal in the case of Arkema Paroxides India Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE, Pondicherry; Goodluck Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Commissioner of C. Ex, Noida [2013 (32)S.T.R.123 (Tribunal)] and Innovasynth Technologies (I) Ltd. v. CCE, Raigad [2015 (38)S.T.R.1232 (Tribunal)]. They submitted that with respect to Rent-a-cab services, such services were used for transportation of their employees from the factory to the customer’s premises for the purpose of installation of the final products at the customer’s premises and placed reliance on the decision of this Hon’ble Tribunal in the case of BSNL v. CST Chennai-II and the decision of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of CCE, Chennai-II Commissionerate v. Hyderabad Industries Ltd.
 
Respondent’s Contention-The ld. AR Shri S. Govindarajan, A. C. submitted that such input services in order to be eligible for credit must have nexus with the manufacture of final product and all the parts of the definition should be satisfied so as that input services becomes an eligible input.
 
Reasoning Of Judgement-Heard both sides On going through the appeal records, tribunal find that expenses incurred on services at the factory premises of the appellant-assessee are eligible as input service. As regards the service of commissioning and installation, the said services are employed only to install the final product at the premises of the customer and only upon such installation, the final product would become operational and purpose of manufacture would fructify. Therefore, the submission of the learned Counsel for the appellant cannot be faulted with and the order of the learned Additional Commissioner in appellant’s own case whereby the learned adjudicating authority has allowed the credit on Commissioning and installation services also strengthens their case.
Regarding Housekeeping services, tribunal find that the said services are employed by the appellants only in compliance of Environmental laws and in particular the Factories Act, 1948, and when money is spent for the purposes of maintaining the factory premises clean and tidy, and the same is includible in the value of the final product, following the decision of the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of C. Ex & ST, LTU Chennai v. Rane TRW Steering Systems - 2015 (39)S.T.R.13 (Mad.) as well as decision in the case of - Hinduja Foundries Ltd. v. CCE, Chennai-I - 2016 (42)S.T.R.494 (Tri.-Chennai), tribunal hold that credit of Service Tax paid on such services cannot be denied.
As regards Air travel services, when it is not in dispute that the said services were employed only for the company’s executives to travel to achieve the business objective and the same has not been used for the employee’s personal needs, credit of Service Tax paid on such services cannot be denied in view of the decision in the cases of Arkema Paroxides India Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE, Pondicherry - 2016-TIOL-1353-CESTAT-MAD, Goodluck Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Commissioner of C. Ex, Noida - 2013 (32)S.T.R.123 (Tri.-Del.) and Innovasynth Technologies (I) Ltd. v. CCE, Raigad - 2015 (38)S.T.R.1232 (Tri.-Mum.).
With respect to Rent-a-cab service, the Counsels for the appellant submitted that such services are employed only for the employees to travel to the customer’s site in order to install the goods and without such installation, the product cannot be functional and such services are not used for the personal consumption of the employees. tribunal find that, the nature of the business of the appellants is such that employees need to travel to the customer’s site to install the products and only on such installation the products would become operational. The very purpose of manufacture of such products is only to benefit the customer for whom it is made and that being the case, cab operator’s services used for the transport of employees to the customer’s site is an integral part to the manufacture of the final products and credit on the same cannot be denied. By respectfully following the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble High Courts as mentioned above,  tribunal allow the assessees appeal in respect of Cenvat credit on input services, such as, commissioning and installation, housekeeping services, air travel services and rent-a-cab services. The penalty is also set aside.
 
Decision- appeal allowed

Comment-The essence of the case is thatCenvat credit on Input service such as Commissioning and Installation services used for installing final product at customer’s premises, eligible to input service credit inasmuch as without such installation product would not be operational. Cenvat credit on Input service such as Housekeeping services availed for maintaining factory premises clean in factory and value of such services included in value of final product. Cenvat credit on Input service such Air Travel services utilized by company’sthatexecutives in relation to business activity and not in their personal needs.Cenvat credit on Input service such as Rent-a-Cab service availed for visiting customer’s site for installation of final product is an integral part of manufacture. Hence,Cenvat credit on input services ,such as, commissioning and installation, housekeeping services, air travel services and rent-a-cab services shall be allowed.
 
Prepared by –  Pushpa choudhary

Department News


Query

 
PRADEEP JAIN, F.C.A.

Head Office : -

Address :
"SUGYAN", H - 29, SHASTRI NAGAR, JODHPUR (RAJ.) - 342003

Phone No. :
0291 - 2439496, 0291 - 3258496

Mobile No. :
09314722236

Fax No. :0291 - 2439496


Branch Office : -

Address:
1008, 10th FLOOR, SUKH SAGAR COMPLEX,
NEAR FORTUNE LANDMARK HOTEL, USMANPURA,
ASHRAM ROAD, AHMEDABAD-380013

Phone No. :
079-32999496, 27560043

Mobile No. :
093777659496, 09377649496

E-mail :pradeep@capradeepjain.com