Chartered Accountant
Bookmark and Share
click here to subscribe our newsletter
 
 
Corporate News *   Government ignored warnings over GST rollout: sources *  GSTR 3B questionaire introduced- To be filled before filing return *  Advisory mail  to all the taxpayers received from GSTN *   Advisory group on GST submits report, suggests changes *   GST lifted oil demand on higher vehicle sales, says report *   Moody’s gives thumbs up to GST, demonetisation  *   Pass on rate cut benefits immediately, companies tell traders *   Focus will now be on simplifying forms, IT processes under GST: Sushil Modi *  Tax rates lowered on consumer goods,only luxury goods taxed @ 28% *   Businesses can revise GST transition claim form now *  Multiplex owners in UP demand clarity on refund as tax exemptions go away after GST *   GST compliance: A case of much ado about nothing *  PM hints more relief for traders & businesses to ease GST compliance burden *  Infosys deploys more people in states to ease GSTN load *   Further reforms are needed for the GST to succeed *   GST impact! Massive stock clearance discounts on apparels, gadgets likely in December *  Kerala HC releases Detained Goods since State has No Power to make Rules to regulate Inter-State movement of Goods under GST *  Infosys is to blame for GST Network glitches, say government officials *   Publishers versus authors: Who will pay GST on royalty? *   कपड़ा निर्यातकों ने कहा, जीएसटी के कारण भारत से शिपमेंट में आ सकती है भारी कमी *   Tax professionals protest over GST returns filing in Gujarat *  Publishers versus authors: Who will pay GST on royalty? *   Pilot Implementation of Paperless Processing under SWIFT *   Anti-dumping duty levied on the imports of " Color Coated/ Pre-Painted flat products of alloy or non-alloy steel " s *   Anti-dumping duty levied on the imports of "Wire Rod of Alloy or Non- Alloy Steel "   *   Exemption on goods imported by EOUs from integrated tax and compensation cess   *   Fixation of Tariff Value of Edible Oils, Brass Scrap, Poppy Seeds, Areca Nut, Gold and Sliver  *   Appointment of Common Adjudicating Authority by DGRI  *   Amendment in various Customs exemption notifications to exempt Integrated Tax/Cess on import of goods under AA/EPCG schemes  *   BCD and IGST rates on certain goods prescribed  
Subject News *   Vide the notification 71/2017-Central Tax ,dt. 29-12-2017, the Central government seeks to extend the time limit for filing FORM GSTR-1 in relation to outward taxable supplies for taxpayers having aggregate turnover upto  Rs. 1.5 Crore for the Quarter JUL-SEPT 2017 to 10th  January,2018. *   Vide the notification 72/2017-Central Tax ,dt. 29-12-2017, the Central government seeks to extend the time limit for filing FORM GSTR-1 in relation to outward taxable supplies for taxpayers having aggregate turnover more than  Rs. 1.5 Crore for the month JUL-NOV  to 10th  January,2018.   *   Vide the notification 73/2017-Central Tax ,dt. 29-12-2017the Central Government seeks to waive the late fees payable by registered person for failure in filing of FORM GSTR-4.   *   Vide the notification 74/2017-Central Tax ,dt. 29-12-2017 the government seeks to notify February 1, 2018 as the date from which the provisions of E-Way Bill Rules shall come into force. *     Vide the notification 75/2017-Central Tax ,dt. 29-12-2017 the Central Government seeks to make amendments in  Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017. *   Inter - State e - way Bill to be made compulsory from 1st of February, 2018 ; system to be ready by 16th of January, 2018 *  Customs (Furnishing of Information) Rules, 2017 introduced *  GST network simplifies return filing process *   State FMs speak on GST implementation, bringing petrol under its ambit *  Shaky Budget in offing? *   GST woes dominate pre-Budget consultations to Arun Jaitley from stakeholders *   Anti-profiteering: Filing complaints against firms not an easy task *   Putting electricity in GST *   12%, 18% GST rates can be merged to new slab *  Inter state movement of rigs,tools and spares, and all goods on wheels (like cranes) would not attract IGST *   GST rate on terricotta idols is NIL rated *   All taxpayers  exempt from payment of tax on advances received in case of supply of goods *   Suppliers of services through an e-commerce platform are exempted from obtaining compulsory registration *   Refund of unutilized input tax credit of GST paid on inputs in respect of exporters of fabrics vide cicular no 18/2017 GST dt 16.11.17 *   Govt tells companies to pass on GST gains immediately *   Anti-profiteering authority to be set up under GST *   CBEC prescribes procedure for manual filing and processing of refund claims for zero rated supplies *  Changes in Tax rate of permanent transfer of Intellectual Property *  GST on Services by way of admission to protected monuments shall be exempted. *  Relevant Notification to be issued shortly, so as to be made available from 15th of November'17 *  Late fee payable for those where a tax liability arises will be Rs. 50/- per day. *  Supply of services by Composition taxpayer upto Rs 5 lakh per annum will be allowed *  Restaurants in hotel premises having room tariff of less than Rs 7500 per unit per day will attract GST of 5% without ITC. *  Restaurants in hotel premises having room tariff of Rs 7500 and above per day (even for a single room) will attract GST of 18% with full ITC. *  Job work services in relation to manufacture of those handicraft goods in respect of which the casual taxable person has been exempted from registration, shall be reduced to 5% with full ITC.  

Comments

Print   |    |  Comment

PJ/Case Law/2016-2017/3445

can seized goods be released after payment of duty and penalty?

Case-SANDEEP GUPTA versus COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE
Citation-2017(345) E.L.T.79 (ALL.)
Issue-can seized goods be released after payment of duty and penalty?
Brief Facts- The facts of the present case are that the petitioner is the proprietor of the firms M/s. Sandeep Manufacturing Strips (a manufacturing unit) and M/s. Sandeep Metal Supply (a trading company). The manufacturing unit was situated at Loni, Ghaziabad whereas the trading unit was situated at Chawri Bazar, Delhi. The two units of which the petitioner was the proprietor were engaged in manufacturing and trading respectively of copper items falling under Chapter Heading 74 of Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. A search was conducted in the premises of M/s. Sandeep Manufacturing Strips, Loni, Ghaziabad and the goods were seized/detained vide Panchanama order dated 27-10-2010. The business premises of M/s. Sandeep Metal Supply was also searched and the goods were seized/detained vide Panchanama of even date.The contention of the petitioner was that there was no illegality in the business activities of the petitioner and, therefore, the search and detention affected on 27-7-2010 was illegal. The detention order was liable to be lifted.
It appeared that a show cause notice was issued by the Directorate General Central Excise Intelligence, New Delhi on 25-1-2011 calling upon the petitioner to show cause as to why the items of copper seized from the premises of M/s. Sandeep Metal Supply weighing 5317.11 Kgs. and valued at Rs. 1,91,43,040/- be not confiscated under Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 and further 4522 Kgs. of Copper ingots, 4413 Kgs. of copper strips seized from the factory premises of M/s. Sandeep Metal Strips, Loni, Ghaziabad be also not confiscated under the aforesaid Rules. A sum of Rs. 22,42,584/- towards Central Excise duty and Rs. 44,852/- as Education Cess and Rs. 22,426/- as Higher Education Cess be not demanded and recovered under Section 11A(1) of the Central Excise Act, 1944. Interest, penalty and seizure of vehicle as also penalty for abetting for commission of the offence be not imposed. Vide letter dated 17-2-2011, the Additional Commissioner, Central Excise Commissionerate, Ghaziabad had informed that the seized goods can be released provisionally after completing the prescribed formalities i.e. after execution of the B-11 Bond equal to the value of goods seized backed by security equal to 25% of the Bond amount.
Appellant’s Contention-Sri Sinha, learned Counsel submitted that the petitioner was prepared to deposit the amount of excise duty and penalty which may be imposed on the seized goods and, thereafter, the seized goods be released. A further plea was raised that the respondents were not supplying the legible copies of the relied upon documents in the show cause notice and, therefore, the petitioner was not in a position to submit the explanation/reply. He submitted that on account of the seizure of the goods, the petitioner’s business was being adversely affected.
Respondent’s Contention-Sri Kesarwani, learnedSenior Standing Counsel appearing for the Respondents No. 1 & 2 , submitted that regarding the grievance of not providing the legible copies of the relied upon documents, the same did not hold good, as on 19-12-2011, the legible copies of all the relied upon documents were given to the petitioner. Photostat copy of the acknowledgement given by Sandeep Gupta, the proprietor was also produced. This fact has not been disputed by the learned Counsel for the petitioner. Thus, the grievance of not supplying of legible copies of relied upon documents did no longer exist.
 
Reasoning Of Judgement- it was held thatSo far as the question of release of the seized goods were concerned, bench may mention here that in the show cause notice dated 25-1-2011, the Directorate General of Central Excise Intelligence, Delhi had specifically asked the petitioner to show cause as to why the goods seized from the premises of M/s. Sandeep Metal Supply and M/s. Sandeep Manufacturing Strips be not confiscated. Adjudication proceedings were yet to be finalised. If ultimately, the authority comes to the conclusion that the seized goods were liable to be confiscated, then in the discretion of the adjudicating authority, an option can be given to the offending party to redeem it on payment of certain amount. What would be that amount at present was only a guess which bench were not inclined to make.
The submission of Sri Sinha that the seized goods may be released on deposit of the amount of Excise duty which was likely to be levied, if accepted at this stage even when the adjudication proceedings were yet to be completed would set at naught the statutory provisions which provided for confiscation of seized goods and its release on payment of redemption amount. Bench may mention here that the duty and penalty which may be imposed was in addition to the confiscation of goods, if ordered and was not in lieu thereof. That being the position, bench cannot direct the release of seized goods on payment of Excise duty and penalty, which may be imposed.
Bench herein observed that the adjudication proceedings have been pending since 25-1-2011. For one reason or the other, it has been held up. As the legible copies of relied upon documents have already been supplied to the petitioner on 19-12-2011, bench directed the petitioner to submit his reply/explanation within a period of one month from today and the Respondent No. 1 or the authorised officer, who had issued the notice dated 25-1-2011 shall pass the final order in accordance with law within one month thereafter.
Decision- writ dismissed.
Comment-The kernel of the case was that when a search is conducted and the goods are seized/ detained then goods cannot be released merely on payment of duty and penalty. As here the adjudication proceedings were not concluded and Quantum of redemption fine was not known  ordering release of goods would make statutory confiscation provision redundant. Since payment of duty and penalty is not in lieu of redemption fine, release of seized goods was held to be not permissible.
Prepared By-arundhati bajpai

Department News


Query

 
PRADEEP JAIN, F.C.A.

Head Office : -

Address :
"SUGYAN", H - 29, SHASTRI NAGAR, JODHPUR (RAJ.) - 342003

Phone No. :
0291 - 2439496, 0291 - 3258496

Mobile No. :
09314722236

Fax No. :0291 - 2439496


Branch Office : -

Address:
1008, 10th FLOOR, SUKH SAGAR COMPLEX,
NEAR FORTUNE LANDMARK HOTEL, USMANPURA,
ASHRAM ROAD, AHMEDABAD-380013

Phone No. :
079-32999496, 27560043

Mobile No. :
093777659496, 09377649496

E-mail :pradeep@capradeepjain.com