Chartered Accountant
Bookmark and Share
click here to subscribe our newsletter
 
 
Corporate News *  Biodegradable packing bags attract 5% GST subject to proof of biodegradability: AAR. *  Biodegradable packing bags attract 5% GST subject to proof of biodegradability: AAR. *  Customs broker’s KYC documents can’t be rejected merely for not meeting exporters: Delhi High Court. *  Old VAT bill book alone can’t prove GST evasion: GSTAT. *  No consignment note, No GTA service tax: CESTAT quashes Rs. 2.73 Crore demand against truck operator. *  70:30 GST formula can’t be compulsorily applied to Pre-2019 solar EPC supplies: Supreme Court. *  GST sanction objection can’t invalidate entire FIR also alleging BNS offences: Calcutta High Court. *  Printing Question Papers, Marksheets, Degree Certificates For Educational Institutions Exempt From GST: AAR *  Kraft paper bags attract 5% GST with ITC: AAR *  Agricultural use doesn’t entitle plastic nursery pots And seedling trays to lower GST; 18% applies: AAR *  E-Way Bill numbers to expand to 14 digits from January 1, 2027; GSTN advises software and API updates. *  Seized vehicle’s release sought over 6 month customs notice limit: Gauhati High Court directs decision on interim custody plea. *  ICEGATE glitch: CESTAT allows appeal against denial of ?4.33 Lakh customs interest refund. *  Missing E-way bill: GSTAT quashes unreasoned relief order, remands tax and penalty dispute. *  Taxpayer can’t be worse off after own appeal: GSTAT caps tax, penalty at ?45 lakh each in suppressed sales case. *  GSTR-3B–GSTR-2A mismatch alone can’t sustain input tax credit demand: GSTAT *  CBIC directs no further GST arrests, bars notices below Rs. 10K and restricts E-way bill checks. *  Importer alleges backdated DIN in arrest documents: Mumbai Court grants bail in ?31.86 crore Customs Duty evasion case. *  GST interest recovery after time-barred assessment set aside: MP High Court *  GST demand based on return scrutiny requires prior ASMT-10 notice: Gauhati High Court. *  GST hearing notices sent to wrong email: disputed service must be examined in statutory appeal: Delhi High Court *  Car dealer’s sales incentives, trade discounts not liable to service tax: CESTAT *  GSTAT may refuse appeals involving up to Rs. 50,000: GSTAT. *  Insurance premium remitted to insurer cannot be added to lender’s taxable service value: CESTAT. *  GST provisional attachment ends after one year: Delhi High Court declines immediate release of ?57.89 Lakh. *  Customs can’t apply new 100-unit import limit retrospectively: Telangana High Court quashes confiscation of used MFDs. *  E-Way bill Part-B lapse alone can’t justify GST penalty without intent to evade tax: GSTAT. *  Railway construction work doesn’t automatically qualify for 12% GST: GSTAT. *  GST exemption for northeast helicopter travel, coffee curing; GTA relief restricted for E-commerce goods from 1 November, 2026: FinMin. *  GST amendment allows same-line business ITC for hotels, restaurants and caterers from 1 November, 2026: FinMin.
Subject News *  Supreme Court stays GST demands on Corporate Guarantees. *  Customs Penalties u/s 112, 114 doesn’t bar special warehouse licence: CESTAT. *  Supplies to SEZ developers before December 2008 eligible for CENVAT relief: Karnataka High Court. *  Customs can’t club demands to meet Rs. 1 crore appeal limit: Delhi High Court. *  GST on mining royalty: Gujarat High Court bars final orders without its permission, allows adjudication to continue. *  Dept. can’t challenge fine alone while leaving related penalty findings uncontested: GSTAT. *  Engineering consultancy for Indian project supplied to Japan not liable to service tax: CESTAT. *  Export overvaluation can be examined without fresh customs valuation: Delhi High court restores drawback recovery order. *  Wrong TRAN-1 column can’t defeat admitted Rs. 6.29 crore GST transitional credit: Bombay High Court. *  Bombay High Court quashes customs order after challenge over alleged AI-generated Supreme Court judgments. *  DGFT can’t reject import registration over HS code mismatch without opportunity to explain: Bombay High Court. *  GST notice despite advance ruling: Gujarat High court restrains final order without its permission. *  Common GST SCN not defective merely because it covers multiple noticees: Delhi High Court. *  GST interest recovery after time-barred assessment set aside: MP High Court. *  Excess stock estimated by eye can’t justify GST confiscation: GSTAT *  Customs can’t retain seized cash without timely notice or valid extension: Supreme Court leaves Rs. 1 lakh costs against DRI intact. *  Surat DGGI | further investigation can’t continue endlessly: Gujarat High Court grants bail in Rs. 43–44 crore fake GST input tax credit case. *  Customs broker’s hearsay statement, ?1.5 lakh transfer insufficient to establish nexus with heroin import: Bombay High Court grants NDPS bail. *  Seized diary entries alone can’t establish suppressed GST turnover without transaction-wise verification: GSTAT. *  Invoice numbering error can’t justify detention of areca nuts, ?6.65 lakh GST penalty: GSTAT. *  GST pre-deposit refund can’t be denied merely because dept. files appeal: CBIC. *  No reverse charge service tax on services received before April 18, 2006: CESTAT. *  Supplier’s retrospective GST cancellation alone can’t deny input tax credit; fraud must be established under section 74: GSTAT. *  E-Invoice portal glitch can’t justify 200% GST penalty without intent to evade tax: GSTAT. *  Cascading effect’ can’t override ?2 crore appeal limit: Delhi High Court dismisses Service Tax Appeals. *  GSTR-1 duplication can’t create tax liability without second supply: GSTAT. *  GST penalty can’t rest on driver’s uncorroborated statement when iron scrap matches valid documents: GSTAT. *  Accountant’s absence delayed stock entries: GSTAT rejects deptartment’s plea for confiscation. *  GST registration restored: Deptartment’s appeal becomes infructuous despite illegal delay condonation: GSTAT. *  Belated ITC-03 filing warrants fresh review of GST composition scheme denial: Madras High Court  

Comments

Print   |    |  Comment

GST update /2026-27/0118

Bharat Aluminium Company Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise & CGST (Audit)-Indore

GST UPDATE

 
Service Tax Appeal No.: 55329 of 2023
Tribunal: CESTAT (New Delhi)
Case Title: Bharat Aluminium Company Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise & CGST (Audit)-Indore
Outcome:Appeal filed by Department was dismissed.
Judgement Date: 14.10.2026
 

QUESTION BEFORE HON’BLE TRIBUNAL:

Whether supply of water by the state government is to be constituted as supply of service as assignment of  a right to use natural resources or such agreement constitutes supply for sale of water?

BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE:

  • M/s Bharat Aluminum Co. Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Appellant) entered into an agreement with Chattisgarh water resources department for supply of water required for the power plant. As per the agreement, appellant was required to make its own arrangements for construction of civil and mechanical works to carry the water from the barrage and had to pay water charges as fixed by the Chattisgarh water resources department. Later on an investigation was conducted by the DGGI, Raipur. During investigation, based on the observation of the agreement it was held that the agreement entered with the State government, assigned the right to use natural resources i.e. water to the appellant as per Section 66D(a)(14) of the Act and was chargeable to service tax w.e.f. 01.04.2016. Furthermore, it was held that by virtue of S. No. 6 of Notification no. 13/2012-ST dated 20.06.2012.
  • Aggrieved by the order, respondent preferred an appeal before the Learned Commissioner (Appeals). Appellate authority set aside the order in original passed by the adjudicating authority and dropped the demand. Being aggrieved by the order of appellate authority, revenue preferred appeal before the Goods and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT).
BRIEF ARGUMENTS BY APPELLANT
Appellant submitted following contentions: -
  • That the agreement was for the supply of water, therefore, the transaction was of sale and not of service. For this reliance was placed upon the decision of tribunal in the case of Sasan power limited v. Commissioner, Central Excise & CGST, Jabalpur in which it was held that water is treated as goods under that act is recognized commercial committee.
  • That Section 65B (44)of the Act expresslyexcludes transfer of title in goods from the definition of service. Trading of goods is also expressly covered by the negative list under Section 66D of the CGST Act;
  • Furthermore, even if it is considered as a service, it is squarely covered by the exemption notification no. 25/2012-ST which exempts any service provided by the government or a local authority to business entities in relation to any of the functions entrusted to the municipality under Article 243(W) of the Constitution and twlfth schedule of the constitution expressly includes water supply for domestic industrial and commercial purposes as a municipal function vide Entry no. 5.
  • Along with that, the extended period of limitation is not invokable in the instant case as an entire question is merely of representation and is revenue neutral in nature as any service tax paid under reverse charge would have admissible to the appellant as CENVAT credit. Thus, it cannot be said that the appellant had any intention to evade payment of service tax.
  •  
Therefore, impugned order in appeal should be set aside.
 

BRIEF ARGUMENTS BY THE DEPARTMENT:

Following are the submissions made by the department:
  • It was argued that the agreement granted permission to the appellant to draw specific quantity of water against payment of water charges. Agreement mandated the appellant to pay water charges of at least 90% of the total quantum of water allowed to be drawn irrespective of actual quantity of water drawn if it is 90%. Further, it is that if the water level in the water body reduces the executive engineer would serve a notice consequent upon it, appellant had to reduce the water consumption.
  • Further, it was argued that the engineer in chief, by letter dated 02.11.2017 informed that the water allotted by the state government to the industry cannot be treated as sale of water as there is no provision of sale of water in Chhattisgarh Irrigation Act. Thus, it was contended that the agreement granted a right to the appellant to use a natural resources, namely water which is squarely covered as a service under Section 66D.
  • As the appellant has not paid service tax and had not respondend to the summons issued by the department. Thus, extended period of limitation is correctly invoked.
 

FINDINGS & JUDGEMENT:

Following are the findings of the Tribunal in the instant case:
Based on the contentions of both the parties, following are the observations and judgment of the Tribunal:
Transaction does not involves supply of service based upon judgement of Tribunal in a previously settled case:
  • It was observed that the question was already decided by the Tribunal in the case of Sasan power Limited in which it was held that such agreements was essentially an agreement for supply of water and not merely an agreement for access to water resource. Appellant draw the water from the water body and make arrangements to carry the water to its plant by itself. Further, it was observed that the instant decision was also followed in subsequent cases. Thus, it was held that the agreement is one of sale of water and not of assignment of right to use natural resources. Therefore, it was held that the demand cannot be sustained and thus deserves to be set aside.
Transaction is Revenue Neutral in naute:
  • Further, it was held that even if the appellant paid any service tax under RCM, it could have immediately availed CENVAT credit of the service tax so paid and utilized it to pay the central excise duty on its final products. Therefore, the entire exercise is revenue neutral. Thus, even if the demand is confirmed, the appellant was entitled to the CENVAT credit and since the CENVAT credit rules are no longer in force as per Section 142 of CGST Act, 2017. The appellant is required to CENVAT credit rules are no longer in force as per Section 142 of CGST Act.
Thus, it was held that the even if the demand is confirmed, appellant was entitled to CENVAT credit and since the CENVAT credit rules are no longer in force as per Section 142 of CGST Act, the appellant will be entitled to cash refund of any service tax so paid.Based on above observations, it was held that demand cannot be sustained even on the ground of limitation. Thus, the appeal was allowed on merits and on limitation and impugned order was set aside along with consequential relief.

 
Department News


Query

 
PRADEEP JAIN, F.C.A.

Head Office : -

Address :
"SUGYAN", H - 29, SHASTRI NAGAR, JODHPUR (RAJ.) - 342003

Phone No. :
0291 - 2439496, 0291 - 3258496

Mobile No. :
09314722236

Fax No. :0291 - 2439496


Branch Office : -

Address:
1008, 10th FLOOR, SUKH SAGAR COMPLEX,
NEAR FORTUNE LANDMARK HOTEL, USMANPURA,
ASHRAM ROAD, AHMEDABAD-380013

Phone No. :
079-32999496, 27560043

Mobile No. :
093777659496, 09377649496

E-mail :pradeep@capradeepjain.com